The Guild

This analysis has to sting:

Now, as soon as anyone from this non-institutional world produces effects within the institutional orbit, it is actually a really serious survival reflex for all institutionally privileged intellectuals to play the morality card (“no platform!”). If all these strange, outside autodidacts are actually smart and independently producing high-level intellectual content you don’t have the time to even understand, let alone defeat or otherwise control, this is an existential threat to your entire livelihood. Because all of your personal identity, your status, and your salary, is based directly on your credentialed, legitimated membership card giving your writings and pontifications an officially sanctioned power and authority. If that door is opened even a crack by non-credentialed outsiders, the whole jig is up for the respectable bourgeois monopoly on the official intellectual organs of society.

Murphy understands that protectionism is the real story, and the Internet is the ultimate context. What began with textile workers has now reached the functionaries of higher education, and they know it. Creative destruction is coming.

4 thoughts on “The Guild

  1. Things NRx and rad-left agree on: to hell with the Cathedral/establishment liberalism

    I do think he’s overstating the protectionist case a little — my money is that it’s more akin to an ‘intellectual’ allergic reaction

    • most of how one becomes an academic is about the socialization and the usual totems and taboos of in and out groups apply.

Leave a Reply